Indulge in a unique dessert experience with our delightful soft serve ice cream pies! Perfect for any occasion, our menu features a variety of handcrafted pies, each layered with creamy soft serve and delicious toppings. Order yours today and treat yourself to a memorable sweet treat.
Featured Soft Serve Ice Cream Pie Creations
Explore our menu of signature soft serve ice cream pies, each crafted with a unique combination of flavors and textures. From classic chocolate combinations to fruity and nutty delights, there’s a perfect pie for every palate.
The Aggie Pie
The Aggie Pie is a peanut butter lover’s dream! Starting with a crunchy Oreo crust, we layer creamy peanut butter soft serve and classic vanilla soft serve. It’s then drizzled with rich hot fudge and peanut butter sauce, and sprinkled with puppy chow. To top it all off, we add mini buckeyes, mini chocolate chips, and a swirl of chocolate whipped cream. This pie is a decadent and satisfying treat.
The Margot Pie
For the Oreo enthusiast, The Margot Pie is a must-try. Built on an Oreo crust, this pie features a delightful combination of chocolate and vanilla soft serve. We then drizzle it with hot fudge and generously sprinkle Oreo cookie crumble throughout. The finishing touch is a crown of cookies-and-cream whipped cream, making it an irresistible cookies and cream experience in every slice.
The Myra Pie
Refresh your taste buds with The Myra Pie! This mint-chocolate sensation starts with an Oreo crust and layers chocolate and vanilla soft serve. We add a refreshing twist with hot fudge, mini mint chips, and mint-chocolate cookie crumble. Topped with mint whipped cream, The Myra Pie offers a cool and invigorating dessert option, perfect for mint chocolate lovers.
The Ruby Pie
The Ruby Pie is a fruity and delightful choice. Beginning with a graham cracker crust, we layer strawberry and vanilla soft serve for a balanced flavor profile. Strawberry compote adds a burst of real fruit flavor, while candied pretzel crunch provides a satisfying textural contrast. Strawberry-shortcake crumble and strawberry whipped cream complete this pie, offering a taste of summer in every bite.
The Lola Pie
Experience a tangy and sweet treat with The Lola Pie. This pie features a graham cracker crust filled with smooth vanilla soft serve. Key lime curd adds a zesty and refreshing citrus element, complemented by graham cracker crumble. Finished with lime curd and vanilla whipped cream, The Lola Pie is a perfect balance of tart and sweet.
The Daisy Pie
Celebrate every day with The Daisy Pie! Built on a graham cracker crust, this fun pie combines strawberry and vanilla soft serve. We add chopped circus animal cookies and birthday cake crumble for a playful touch. Lemon buttercream and Funfetti sprinkles complete this festive creation, making it a joyful and colorful dessert option.
The Sadie Pie
The Sadie Pie is for those who crave a rich and complex flavor profile. Starting with a graham cracker crust, we layer vanilla soft serve and peanut butter-marshmallow fluff. Snickers bits, hot fudge, maple bourbon caramel, and chopped peanuts add layers of indulgence. Chocolate ganache finishes this pie, creating a decadent and nutty treat.
The Scout Pie
The Scout Pie offers a caramel and coconut dream. An Oreo crust forms the base, followed by caramel and vanilla soft serve. Samoa-cookie crumble and coconut-Rice Krispie crunch add delightful textures and flavors. Hot fudge, caramel sauce, and Oreo whipped cream complete this pie, creating a rich and satisfying dessert experience.
Chocolate Sampler Pie
Can’t decide? Try our Chocolate Sampler Pie! This pie features a quarter each of our Aggie, Margot, Myra, and Sadie pies, giving you a taste of all our chocolate soft serve ice cream pie goodness in one delicious sampler. It’s the perfect option for sharing or for those who want to experience a variety of flavors.
The Beatrice Pie
The Beatrice Pie is a coffee and caramel lover’s delight. An Oreo crust is filled with two layers of vanilla soft serve, creating a creamy base. Caramel sauce and espresso pudding add rich and decadent flavors. Chocolate cookie crumble and vanilla whipped cream complete this pie, offering a sophisticated and satisfying dessert.
Ordering Your Soft Serve Ice Cream Pie
Ready to order your perfect soft serve ice cream pie? Please note the following order instructions:
- Pickup Location & Date: Choose your preferred pickup location and date at least 48 hours after placing your order.
- Customization: For dairy-free vanilla soft serve, please specify in the order form during checkout (additional $4 charge upon pickup). For other customization requests, please email [email protected].
Pickup Location:
- 673 Worthington Road (LLSS Shop): Pickups are available daily during normal shop hours.
Treat yourself to a delicious soft serve ice cream pie today!
